• 0 Posts
  • 7 Comments
Joined 4 years ago
cake
Cake day: October 2nd, 2020

help-circle


  • yes, as i said

    from the article it’s not clear what the performance boost is relative to intrinsics

    (they don’t make that comparison in the article)

    so its not clear exactly how handwritten asm compares to intrinsics in this specific comparison. we can’t assume their handwritten AVX-512 asm and instrinics AVX-512 will perform identically here, it may be better, or worse.

    also worth noting they’re discussing benchmarking of a specific function, so overall performance on executing a given set of commands may be quite different depending what can and can’t be unrolled and in which order for different dependencies.


  • from the article it’s not clear what the performance boost is relative to intrinsics (its extremely unlikely to be anything close to 94x lol), its not even clear from the article if the avx2 implementation they benchmarked against was instrinsics or handwritten either. in some cases avx2 seems to slightly outperform avx-512 in their implementation

    there’s also so many different ways to break a problem down that i’m not sure this is an ideal showcase, at least without more information.

    to be fair to the presenters they may not be the ones making the specific flavour of hype that the article writers are.